Could Malaysia Choose to Stop Raising Pigs and Switch to Imported Pork Instead?
Recently, Malaysian lawmaker Wan Saiful Wan Jan raised the following question in Parliament: Since domestic demand for pork can be met through imports, is it necessary for the government to continue maintaining large-scale pig farms?
In his view, rather than dealing with the odors, wastewater, and water pollution caused by pig farms in the long term, it would be better to shut down all domestic pig farms and consider the option of imports. If imported pork is cheaper and can also reduce the inconvenience to local residents, why not choose a “more prudent” solution like Singapore’s?
This is not the first time such a suggestion has been made. Earlier this year, MP Kalam Salan also called for an end to local pig farming.
Currently, the Malaysian government is evaluating the pig farming industry. In March, Mohamad Sabu, Malaysia’s Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, announced that a comprehensive study covering legal, technical, economic, and social aspects of the industry would be conducted. Meanwhile, the state of Selangor has already taken the lead by deciding to gradually shut down local pig farms.
However, when an industrial policy involving environmental governance becomes intertwined with religion, ethnic identity, and the livelihoods of minority groups, the issue is no longer as simple as “raise locally or buy from abroad.”
“Those who haven’t experienced it firsthand may not understand this suffering.”
On October 19, during the policy debate on the 2027 fiscal budget, Wan Saif cited the pig farm in Kampung Selamat, Northern Penang, Malaysia, as an example to describe the long-standing hardships faced by local residents.
According to him, the foul odors and water pollution caused by the pig farm have affected the daily lives of local residents for decades; at times, the stench is so overpowering that it even prevents residents from hosting banquets.
Wan Saif’s own home is not far from the pig farm; he can smell the stench the moment he opens his front door. Nearby residents have also witnessed the river water turning from its natural color to black.
“Those who haven’t experienced it firsthand may not understand this suffering,” Wan Saif said during his speech in Parliament, noting that local residents endure these impacts every day, yet the problem remains unresolved.
He believes that no matter where a pig farm is built, it is bound to face resistance from nearby residents. Rather than continuing to be mired in a tug-of-war over site selection disputes and environmental complaints, it would be better to reassess whether large-scale pig farms still need to exist.
He emphasized that the relevant discussions should focus on practical considerations such as pollution control, public welfare, and industrial sustainability, and avoid escalating into ethnic or religious disputes.
Selangor to Be the First to “Phase Out”
Selangor is Malaysia’s most populous and economically developed state, surrounding Kuala Lumpur with a high concentration of urban and industrial areas. As the city has developed, conflicts between pig farms and residential areas have become increasingly prominent.
Controversy surrounding the local pig farming industry initially centered on issues such as waste disposal, foul odors, mosquitoes, and river pollution. Subsequently, opinions gradually diverged regarding whether pig farms should be allowed to continue operating, where they should be relocated, and whether the government should approve new farming sites.
In January of this year, the Selangor Royal Household opposed the state government’s plan to allow the Tanjung Sepat pig farm to operate temporarily before relocating to the modernized, centralized farming complex in Bukit Tajar. The Royal Household argued that the problems caused by the local pig farming industry had remained unresolved for a long time and explicitly opposed the continued operation of pig farms in Selangor.
Currently, the Selangor state government has stopped issuing new pig farming licenses and has decided to phase out existing pig farms.
According to Izhan, the state’s head of agricultural affairs, the state government plans to complete the slaughter of live pigs and the clearance of the farms by the end of this year, followed by land rehabilitation and assistance for affected farmers in finding new sources of livelihood.
Going forward, Selangor’s pork supply will rely 100 percent on imports or purchases from other states.
For some farmers, this means a family business they have run for many years may come to an end.
One farmer, who wished to remain anonymous, said that pig farming is the only trade he knows to make a living. If he were to switch to raising chickens or cattle, he would have to start from scratch—and he is also “burdened with debt.”
“All I can do now is pray to God,” he sighed helplessly.
Izzhan said that some pig farmers have already begun switching to crops such as limes, and the state government also plans to assist other operators in applying for agricultural aid grants to transition to new agricultural projects. However, the transition is not simply a matter of switching to a different crop. The farmers’ existing land, equipment, loans, and technical expertise all need to be reorganized.
Modernization Efforts Also Face Practical Challenges
The environmental problems caused by pig farms did not arise overnight. How to treat pig manure, wastewater, and gases generated during the farming process has always been a major challenge.
Lin Jianwen, an engineer with extensive experience in wastewater system design, has noted that pig manure not only has a high carbon content but also contains large amounts of undecomposed fiber and long-chain organic compounds, meaning it cannot be treated by simple sedimentation alone. In traditional, decentralized farming environments lacking enclosed management, the decomposition of manure and wastewater also produces biogas and malodorous gases; among these, hydrogen sulfide not only has a strong odor but is also corrosive.
To meet modern environmental standards, pig farms need to build specialized wastewater treatment systems equipped with the necessary facilities and operating personnel. However, the construction and operational costs of such systems are not insignificant. If the scale of operations is insufficient, the biogas produced cannot be effectively recovered and utilized, making it difficult to spread the associated costs.
The Malaysian government has previously promoted the modernization of the industry. In March of this year, Chen Hongjian, Deputy Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, stated that the government encourages the swine industry to adopt enclosed farming systems, improve waste management, and strengthen environmental protection measures.
According to data released at that time, among Malaysia’s 355 registered pig farms, 121—approximately one-third—had already adopted modern farming models such as enclosed pig barns and zero-discharge concepts.
This also demonstrates that technical solutions to pollution problems do exist. For regions that still wish to retain the pig farming industry, centralized farming, enclosed pig barns, specialized manure treatment, and stricter emission regulations are all viable options worth considering.
However, modernization cannot avoid a pressing practical question: Who will bear the costs?
If farmers are required to meet higher environmental standards but are not provided with sufficient land, financing, and technical support, some small and medium-sized farmers may find it difficult to continue operating. Malaysian agricultural banks generally do not provide loans or financing facilities for the pig farming industry, which further complicates the industry’s transition to modern standards.
Is Malaysia ready to shift from domestic production to imports?
Wansaf believes that the price of imported pork may be lower than that of locally raised pork in Malaysia, and that Singapore’s experience is worth considering.
Singapore has limited land resources, and pig farming requires land and water; it also involves environmental management issues such as manure treatment and odor control. Since the 1980s, Singapore has gradually restricted the development of its pig farming industry, and by the 1990s, domestic pig production had essentially come to an end, leaving the country highly dependent on imports for its pork supply.
But can Malaysia simply replicate this model?
The situation in Malaysia appears to be somewhat different. The country still maintains a domestic pig farming industry of a certain scale and has been actively discussing ways to enhance agricultural self-sufficiency.
In March of this year, Chen Hongjian stated that Malaysia’s pork self-sufficiency rate in 2024 was 67.8 percent, and the government’s goal is to raise this figure to 90 percent by 2030. This suggests that, at least in the policy planning at that time, boosting domestic production capacity remained one of the government’s priorities.
Changes in the number of pig farms and licenses also reflect the pressures facing the industry.
A written response submitted to Parliament on July 13 by Shab, Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, revealed that there are a total of 427 pig farms nationwide, of which 338 hold valid licenses and 89 operate without one. By comparison, official data from 2024 listed 435 licensed pig farms and 52 unlicensed ones.
Based on the above data, the number of licensed pig farms decreased by approximately 22.3% over the two-year period, while the number of unlicensed pig farms increased by approximately 71.2%.
Shab stated that the decline in the number of licensed pig farmers does not affect pork supply, as pork imports from approved overseas slaughterhouses can fill the gap when domestic supply is insufficient.
He had previously revealed during a parliamentary question-and-answer session that Malaysia’s non-Muslim population accounts for approximately 36.5 percent of the total population. In 2025, the country’s pork demand stood at 213,928 metric tons, while local supply reached 221,959 metric tons, indicating an overall balance between supply and demand.
These figures indicate that Malaysia does not currently need to rely on imports immediately to meet its pork demand. Imports can serve as a means of supplementing supply, but if the domestic pig farming industry were to completely cease operations, imports would shift from being a tool for market regulation to the primary method of maintaining supply.
The difference between the two is significant.
Furthermore, whether imported pork can maintain a price advantage in the long term is another point open to debate in Wan Saifuddin’s proposal.
Local farming must bear costs related to land, feed, labor, environmental protection facilities, and disease prevention. For smaller-scale farms with relatively outdated technology, these expenses may further drive up production costs. In contrast, pork from large-scale producing countries may gain a price advantage through economies of scale and mature processing systems.
However, import prices are not a fixed figure. International market conditions, transportation costs, exchange rates, quarantine requirements, and trade policies all affect the final cost upon arrival. Even if imported pork is cheaper during a specific period, it cannot be assumed that it will maintain a price advantage at all times.
Furthermore, Ahmad Ibrahim, a wastewater engineering expert at the Tan Sri Omar Center for Technology and Innovation Policy Research at Universiti Sait, expressed concern that reliance on imports carries the risk of introducing diseases.
Last January, an outbreak of African swine fever occurred in Tanjung Sepat, resulting in the culling of live pigs at approximately half of the local pig farms. Today, African swine fever continues to threaten the global pork supply.
Ibrahim believes that modern, enclosed pig farms equipped with biosecurity corridors can provide a better barrier against disease outbreaks. In contrast, if closing pig farms is viewed as the only solution, it will be necessary to further assess how the country will respond to fluctuations in external supply following a decline in domestic production capacity.
Beyond prices, there are also ripple effects caused by shifts in consumer preferences.
Ibrahim noted that if pork prices rise sharply, some consumers may switch to other protein sources, such as chicken. Consequently, the impact of a contraction in pork supply may not be limited to the pork market alone but could also spill over into other meat products.
The Future of the Pig Farming Industry: More Than Just a Debate Over the Environment and Prices
The Malaysian pig farming industry is particularly sensitive due to the underlying social and political context.
Approximately 63.5 percent of Malaysia’s population is Muslim, and Islam prohibits the consumption of pork. Pork production and consumption are therefore particularly socially sensitive issues, but environmental pollution, land use, and residents’ quality of life are equally pressing challenges that local governments must address.
Bridget Welsh, an Honorary Research Fellow at the University of Nottingham’s Institute of Asian Studies in Malaysia, believes that once issues of faith and identity take center stage, problems that could originally be addressed through technical and managerial measures are easily reduced to an either-or choice.
She noted that in policy discussions regarding the pig farming industry, the religious sensitivities of the majority group may be prioritized, while the space for finding technical solutions that balance the interests of different groups is squeezed.
Malaysia’s Sin Chew Daily previously reported that the core conflict should not be a binary choice of “to raise or not to raise,” but rather how to achieve a balance between environmental protection and industrial development through modernization and technological upgrades.
Given the current global geopolitical tensions, food supply chains are highly vulnerable to disruptions. Whether due to insufficient production capacity, logistics failures, or packaging delays, overreliance on international markets exposes the country to the risk of soaring prices and supply crises.
Malaysia has long advocated for food self-sufficiency, but it remains highly dependent on imports for many staple foods. The problem lies not in a lack of land, but in the absence of comprehensive, long-term land-use and industrial planning. National agricultural policy has long favored cash crops such as oil palm; in recent years, the rising value of durian exports has further prompted farmers to switch crops. As a result, the land available for the production of staple foods—which are vital to people’s livelihoods—has continued to shrink.
In Ibrahim’s view, this issue ultimately serves as a test of Malaysia’s social diversity and inclusivity. “The goal is not to ‘decide a winner or loser,’ but to transform this situation into a model for inclusive and transparent policy-making.”
Disclaimer: Some of the information in this article is sourced from the internet. Sources have been clearly cited, and copyright belongs to the original authors. The content is provided for readers’ reference only. If the rights of the original authors have been infringed, please contact us promptly via comment so we may remove the content!
Recently, Malaysian lawmaker Wan Saiful Wan Jan raised the following question in Parliament: Since domestic demand for pork can be met through imports, is it necessary for the government to continue maintaining large-scale pig farms?
In his view, rather than dealing with the odors, wastewater, and water pollution caused by pig farms in the long term, it would be better to shut down all domestic pig farms and consider the option of imports. If imported pork is cheaper and can also reduce the inconvenience to local residents, why not choose a “more prudent” solution like Singapore’s?
This is not the first time such a suggestion has been made. Earlier this year, MP Kalam Salan also called for an end to local pig farming.
Currently, the Malaysian government is evaluating the pig farming industry. In March, Mohamad Sabu, Malaysia’s Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, announced that a comprehensive study covering legal, technical, economic, and social aspects of the industry would be conducted. Meanwhile, the state of Selangor has already taken the lead by deciding to gradually shut down local pig farms.
However, when an industrial policy involving environmental governance becomes intertwined with religion, ethnic identity, and the livelihoods of minority groups, the issue is no longer as simple as “raise locally or buy from abroad.”
“Those who haven’t experienced it firsthand may not understand this suffering.”
On October 19, during the policy debate on the 2027 fiscal budget, Wan Saif cited the pig farm in Kampung Selamat, Northern Penang, Malaysia, as an example to describe the long-standing hardships faced by local residents.
According to him, the foul odors and water pollution caused by the pig farm have affected the daily lives of local residents for decades; at times, the stench is so overpowering that it even prevents residents from hosting banquets.
Wan Saif’s own home is not far from the pig farm; he can smell the stench the moment he opens his front door. Nearby residents have also witnessed the river water turning from its natural color to black.
“Those who haven’t experienced it firsthand may not understand this suffering,” Wan Saif said during his speech in Parliament, noting that local residents endure these impacts every day, yet the problem remains unresolved.
He believes that no matter where a pig farm is built, it is bound to face resistance from nearby residents. Rather than continuing to be mired in a tug-of-war over site selection disputes and environmental complaints, it would be better to reassess whether large-scale pig farms still need to exist.
He emphasized that the relevant discussions should focus on practical considerations such as pollution control, public welfare, and industrial sustainability, and avoid escalating into ethnic or religious disputes.
Selangor to Be the First to “Phase Out”
Selangor is Malaysia’s most populous and economically developed state, surrounding Kuala Lumpur with a high concentration of urban and industrial areas. As the city has developed, conflicts between pig farms and residential areas have become increasingly prominent.
Controversy surrounding the local pig farming industry initially centered on issues such as waste disposal, foul odors, mosquitoes, and river pollution. Subsequently, opinions gradually diverged regarding whether pig farms should be allowed to continue operating, where they should be relocated, and whether the government should approve new farming sites.
In January of this year, the Selangor Royal Household opposed the state government’s plan to allow the Tanjung Sepat pig farm to operate temporarily before relocating to the modernized, centralized farming complex in Bukit Tajar. The Royal Household argued that the problems caused by the local pig farming industry had remained unresolved for a long time and explicitly opposed the continued operation of pig farms in Selangor.
Currently, the Selangor state government has stopped issuing new pig farming licenses and has decided to phase out existing pig farms.
According to Izhan, the state’s head of agricultural affairs, the state government plans to complete the slaughter of live pigs and the clearance of the farms by the end of this year, followed by land rehabilitation and assistance for affected farmers in finding new sources of livelihood.
Going forward, Selangor’s pork supply will rely 100 percent on imports or purchases from other states.
For some farmers, this means a family business they have run for many years may come to an end.
One farmer, who wished to remain anonymous, said that pig farming is the only trade he knows to make a living. If he were to switch to raising chickens or cattle, he would have to start from scratch—and he is also “burdened with debt.”
“All I can do now is pray to God,” he sighed helplessly.
Izzhan said that some pig farmers have already begun switching to crops such as limes, and the state government also plans to assist other operators in applying for agricultural aid grants to transition to new agricultural projects. However, the transition is not simply a matter of switching to a different crop. The farmers’ existing land, equipment, loans, and technical expertise all need to be reorganized.
Modernization Efforts Also Face Practical Challenges
The environmental problems caused by pig farms did not arise overnight. How to treat pig manure, wastewater, and gases generated during the farming process has always been a major challenge.
Lin Jianwen, an engineer with extensive experience in wastewater system design, has noted that pig manure not only has a high carbon content but also contains large amounts of undecomposed fiber and long-chain organic compounds, meaning it cannot be treated by simple sedimentation alone. In traditional, decentralized farming environments lacking enclosed management, the decomposition of manure and wastewater also produces biogas and malodorous gases; among these, hydrogen sulfide not only has a strong odor but is also corrosive.
To meet modern environmental standards, pig farms need to build specialized wastewater treatment systems equipped with the necessary facilities and operating personnel. However, the construction and operational costs of such systems are not insignificant. If the scale of operations is insufficient, the biogas produced cannot be effectively recovered and utilized, making it difficult to spread the associated costs.
The Malaysian government has previously promoted the modernization of the industry. In March of this year, Chen Hongjian, Deputy Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, stated that the government encourages the swine industry to adopt enclosed farming systems, improve waste management, and strengthen environmental protection measures.
According to data released at that time, among Malaysia’s 355 registered pig farms, 121—approximately one-third—had already adopted modern farming models such as enclosed pig barns and zero-discharge concepts.
This also demonstrates that technical solutions to pollution problems do exist. For regions that still wish to retain the pig farming industry, centralized farming, enclosed pig barns, specialized manure treatment, and stricter emission regulations are all viable options worth considering.
However, modernization cannot avoid a pressing practical question: Who will bear the costs?
If farmers are required to meet higher environmental standards but are not provided with sufficient land, financing, and technical support, some small and medium-sized farmers may find it difficult to continue operating. Malaysian agricultural banks generally do not provide loans or financing facilities for the pig farming industry, which further complicates the industry’s transition to modern standards.
Is Malaysia ready to shift from domestic production to imports?
Wansaf believes that the price of imported pork may be lower than that of locally raised pork in Malaysia, and that Singapore’s experience is worth considering.
Singapore has limited land resources, and pig farming requires land and water; it also involves environmental management issues such as manure treatment and odor control. Since the 1980s, Singapore has gradually restricted the development of its pig farming industry, and by the 1990s, domestic pig production had essentially come to an end, leaving the country highly dependent on imports for its pork supply.
But can Malaysia simply replicate this model?
The situation in Malaysia appears to be somewhat different. The country still maintains a domestic pig farming industry of a certain scale and has been actively discussing ways to enhance agricultural self-sufficiency.
In March of this year, Chen Hongjian stated that Malaysia’s pork self-sufficiency rate in 2024 was 67.8 percent, and the government’s goal is to raise this figure to 90 percent by 2030. This suggests that, at least in the policy planning at that time, boosting domestic production capacity remained one of the government’s priorities.
Changes in the number of pig farms and licenses also reflect the pressures facing the industry.
A written response submitted to Parliament on July 13 by Shab, Minister of Agriculture and Food Security, revealed that there are a total of 427 pig farms nationwide, of which 338 hold valid licenses and 89 operate without one. By comparison, official data from 2024 listed 435 licensed pig farms and 52 unlicensed ones.
Based on the above data, the number of licensed pig farms decreased by approximately 22.3% over the two-year period, while the number of unlicensed pig farms increased by approximately 71.2%.
Shab stated that the decline in the number of licensed pig farmers does not affect pork supply, as pork imports from approved overseas slaughterhouses can fill the gap when domestic supply is insufficient.
He had previously revealed during a parliamentary question-and-answer session that Malaysia’s non-Muslim population accounts for approximately 36.5 percent of the total population. In 2025, the country’s pork demand stood at 213,928 metric tons, while local supply reached 221,959 metric tons, indicating an overall balance between supply and demand.
These figures indicate that Malaysia does not currently need to rely on imports immediately to meet its pork demand. Imports can serve as a means of supplementing supply, but if the domestic pig farming industry were to completely cease operations, imports would shift from being a tool for market regulation to the primary method of maintaining supply.
The difference between the two is significant.
Furthermore, whether imported pork can maintain a price advantage in the long term is another point open to debate in Wan Saifuddin’s proposal.
Local farming must bear costs related to land, feed, labor, environmental protection facilities, and disease prevention. For smaller-scale farms with relatively outdated technology, these expenses may further drive up production costs. In contrast, pork from large-scale producing countries may gain a price advantage through economies of scale and mature processing systems.
However, import prices are not a fixed figure. International market conditions, transportation costs, exchange rates, quarantine requirements, and trade policies all affect the final cost upon arrival. Even if imported pork is cheaper during a specific period, it cannot be assumed that it will maintain a price advantage at all times.
Furthermore, Ahmad Ibrahim, a wastewater engineering expert at the Tan Sri Omar Center for Technology and Innovation Policy Research at Universiti Sait, expressed concern that reliance on imports carries the risk of introducing diseases.
Last January, an outbreak of African swine fever occurred in Tanjung Sepat, resulting in the culling of live pigs at approximately half of the local pig farms. Today, African swine fever continues to threaten the global pork supply.
Ibrahim believes that modern, enclosed pig farms equipped with biosecurity corridors can provide a better barrier against disease outbreaks. In contrast, if closing pig farms is viewed as the only solution, it will be necessary to further assess how the country will respond to fluctuations in external supply following a decline in domestic production capacity.
Beyond prices, there are also ripple effects caused by shifts in consumer preferences.
Ibrahim noted that if pork prices rise sharply, some consumers may switch to other protein sources, such as chicken. Consequently, the impact of a contraction in pork supply may not be limited to the pork market alone but could also spill over into other meat products.
The Future of the Pig Farming Industry: More Than Just a Debate Over the Environment and Prices
The Malaysian pig farming industry is particularly sensitive due to the underlying social and political context.
Approximately 63.5 percent of Malaysia’s population is Muslim, and Islam prohibits the consumption of pork. Pork production and consumption are therefore particularly socially sensitive issues, but environmental pollution, land use, and residents’ quality of life are equally pressing challenges that local governments must address.
Bridget Welsh, an Honorary Research Fellow at the University of Nottingham’s Institute of Asian Studies in Malaysia, believes that once issues of faith and identity take center stage, problems that could originally be addressed through technical and managerial measures are easily reduced to an either-or choice.
She noted that in policy discussions regarding the pig farming industry, the religious sensitivities of the majority group may be prioritized, while the space for finding technical solutions that balance the interests of different groups is squeezed.
Malaysia’s Sin Chew Daily previously reported that the core conflict should not be a binary choice of “to raise or not to raise,” but rather how to achieve a balance between environmental protection and industrial development through modernization and technological upgrades.
Given the current global geopolitical tensions, food supply chains are highly vulnerable to disruptions. Whether due to insufficient production capacity, logistics failures, or packaging delays, overreliance on international markets exposes the country to the risk of soaring prices and supply crises.
Malaysia has long advocated for food self-sufficiency, but it remains highly dependent on imports for many staple foods. The problem lies not in a lack of land, but in the absence of comprehensive, long-term land-use and industrial planning. National agricultural policy has long favored cash crops such as oil palm; in recent years, the rising value of durian exports has further prompted farmers to switch crops. As a result, the land available for the production of staple foods—which are vital to people’s livelihoods—has continued to shrink.
In Ibrahim’s view, this issue ultimately serves as a test of Malaysia’s social diversity and inclusivity. “The goal is not to ‘decide a winner or loser,’ but to transform this situation into a model for inclusive and transparent policy-making.”
Disclaimer: Some of the information in this article is sourced from the internet. Sources have been clearly cited, and copyright belongs to the original authors. The content is provided for readers’ reference only. If the rights of the original authors have been infringed, please contact us promptly via comment so we may remove the content!